← School

Free course

Communicating and leading, a lesson every weekday

A short daily lesson on saying the hard thing, asking for what you need, writing that works without you, and leading people. One framework, one story, one thing to try today.

Name two times: get a meeting on the calendar with one message.

Newest lesson · Lesson 68 · 5:51

You learn to schedule a meeting in one message by naming two specific times, stating your preference, and leaving an easy way out.

Listen to the lesson
  1. 67.Three short lines: how to answer a correction for something you did not do.5:24You learn how to answer a false correction in three short lines: the fact, the rule going forward, and when they will hear from you.
    Play lesson
    5:24

    Imagine you are a bookkeeper who works from a small office above a hardware store, keeping the books for a dozen local businesses. Late on Sunday evening one of your clients, the owner of a family garden centre, sends you one line. It says, in effect, we were not supposed to reorganise the accounts before the quarterly returns are filed. And you had not reorganised anything. Nothing had moved. You check twice, just to be sure, and the answer is still no, it did not happen. Today's lesson is what to write back when somebody corrects you for a thing you never did.

    It is an easy reply to get wrong, and there is a reason. Douglas Stone and Sheila Heen, the Harvard negotiation teachers who wrote Thanks for the Feedback, sorted the ways feedback sets us off into three triggers. The truth trigger fires when the content is just wrong. The relationship trigger fires because of who said it and how they treat us. The identity trigger fires when it touches the story we tell about who we are. A wrong correction from a client pulls all three at once. It is false. It comes from someone whose tone already wears on you. And it suggests you are careless, when careful is the thing a bookkeeper is selling.

    With all three pulled, two replies come to mind. One proves your innocence at length: four paragraphs with dates and times. The other pushes back: as I mentioned on Friday. Which means, as you would know if you read what I sent.

    John Gottman has a name for both. Gottman is the psychologist who spent decades watching couples argue in his lab at the University of Washington, and he found four habits that predicted which couples would split. One of them is defensiveness. He describes it as protecting yourself with righteous indignation or by playing the innocent victim. He studied couples, not clients, but the mechanism travels. Defensiveness, he found, does not calm the other person down. It tells them their worry was not heard, so they say it again, louder. The garden centre owner had already said it twice.

    Being right is the trap. When you are wrong, you know you have to listen. When you are right, you feel you have earned the long reply. And the long reply to a false charge reads, to the person who made it, exactly like the reply of someone who did it.

    So here is the other way. Stone and Heen say that before you decide whether feedback is right, find out where it is coming from. Under this correction there is a worry, and it is not hard to find. She has returns going out for the quarter. Those returns lean on the accounts as they stand. She is afraid somebody will rearrange the categories while she is standing on them. That worry is completely reasonable. The only thing she has wrong is the fact.

    So the reply has three lines, and the order matters.

    Line one is the fact, with no cushion. Nothing was moved. Three words. No opener about clarifying, and no line about some confusion. Those soften the one thing she most needs to read. She is reading on a phone between sessions at a trade fair. If the first line is the fact, she has what she came for before her thumb moves.

    Line two answers the worry. The reorganising waits until the quarterly returns are filed. Now she knows you heard the rule, and that it holds from here on, not only last night.

    Line three hands her the control she was reaching for. I will tell you before it starts. That is the line that stops the third reminder. She kept repeating herself because she had no way to know it would not happen behind her back. Now she has one.

    Three things stay out. The phrase as I mentioned. The timeline of who wrote what when. And the apology, because there is nothing to be sorry for, and a reflexive sorry would tell her that something did go wrong. Gottman's cure for defensiveness is to take responsibility for your part, even a small part. Sometimes your part is zero. But there is still a piece you own: her not knowing. You can own that without owning a mistake. That is what line three does.

    And notice what you do not do. You do not correct her memory. Whether she misread the earlier note or skimmed it does not matter. You could win that point, and it would cost you the whole reply. The goal is that she puts the phone down thinking, good, that is handled. It is not that she puts it down thinking, I was wrong.

    One more thing, for the bookkeeper and not for the client. Being told off for something you did not do is a small insult, and it is fair to feel it. Say so out loud to a friend, or to anyone who is not her. The email gets the three lines.

    Here is the thing to try today. Think of a correction like this sitting in your own inbox, or the next one that arrives. Write the three lines yourself: the fact, the rule going forward, and when they will hear from you. Keep it under thirty words. Read it once and ask one question. If they read only the first three words, do they have what they need? If yes, send it. Then watch whether the reminder comes a third time.

    Three lines. The fact, the worry, and when they will hear from you.

    Key terms

    Three feedback triggers
    Stone and Heen's idea that feedback sets us off through truth, relationship or identity, and a wrong correction can pull all three at once.
    Defensiveness
    Gottman's name for protecting yourself with indignation or innocence, which signals the other person was not heard and makes them repeat the worry.
    Answering the worry
    Replying to the concern underneath a correction rather than arguing about whether the correction was accurate.

    Say it back

    1. What problem is this lesson helping you avoid?
    2. What is the first move you would make?
    3. Where could you use this in your next conversation?