← School

Free course

Communicating and leading, a lesson every weekday

A short daily lesson on saying the hard thing, asking for what you need, writing that works without you, and leading people. One framework, one story, one thing to try today.

Name two times: get a meeting on the calendar with one message.

Newest lesson · Lesson 68 · 5:51

You learn to schedule a meeting in one message by naming two specific times, stating your preference, and leaving an easy way out.

Listen to the lesson
  1. 53.Earn the right to disagree: push back so the other person actually hears it.6:45You learn how to disagree so people actually hear you: restate their view, agree where you can, credit what you learned, then hedge your criticism.
    Play lesson
    6:45

    Imagine you run a small landscaping business with a crew of four. Today's lesson is about the moment you know someone is wrong. Most people have been there a lot. You see the better answer, you say it, and it goes nowhere. Then you say it again, harder, with more evidence, and it goes nowhere faster. The landscaper meets this every week. A homeowner wants a stone patio laid flat against the back wall, and she can see the rain will pool there and creep into the basement. Her accountant gives advice that sounds too cautious about buying a second truck. The loan officer at the bank wants a repayment term she does not like. With all three, going silent is expensive and going hard is expensive. This lesson is not about being right more often. It is about what decides whether being right counts for anything, which is whether the other person can hear you at the moment you say it.

    The idea comes from a game theorist named Anatol Rapoport. It was written down as a set of rules by the philosopher Daniel Dennett in his two thousand thirteen book Intuition Pumps and Other Tools for Thinking. Dennett calls them Rapoport's rules, and there are four. First, restate the other person's position so clearly, vividly and fairly that they say, thanks, I wish I had put it that way myself. Second, list every point where you agree with them, especially the ones that are not obvious. Third, name anything you have learned from them. And fourth, only after all of that, are you allowed to say one word of criticism.

    Notice what the rules do to the order of the conversation. Most of us open with the disagreement, because the disagreement is what we are excited about. Rapoport puts it last. The three steps before it are not politeness. They are proof. The restatement proves you understood them. The agreement proves you are not just against them. The thing you learned proves you were listening rather than waiting for your turn. By the time you reach the criticism, you have shown them a person worth arguing with, and that changes what they do with your argument.

    This could be a nice idea with no evidence behind it, so here is the research. Julia Minson at Harvard's Kennedy School has spent about a decade studying what she calls receptiveness to opposing views. In a two thousand twenty paper in Management Science with Frances Chen and Catherine Tinsley, she built a way to measure how willing a person is to take in views they oppose. What matters most here is the second paper. In two thousand twenty, Michael Yeomans, Minson, Hanne Collins, Frances Chen and Francesca Gino published a study in Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes called Conversational Receptiveness. They took thousands of written disagreements and worked out which words made the reader feel heard. Four things kept showing up. Openly acknowledging the other view. Hedging your own claims, saying I might be wrong about this rather than stating it flat. Framing things in positive terms, saying what you want rather than what you refuse. And finding a point of agreement. That is Rapoport, measured.

    Then they tested it. When people wrote their disagreement using that recipe, readers saw the message as more persuasive and the writer as more worth working with in the future, even though the position itself had not softened. In a separate study they looked at Wikipedia editors arguing on talk pages, which is about as hostile a written setting as exists. Editors who wrote receptively were less likely to be hit with a personal attack in reply. The way they opened mattered more than they expected.

    Here is why this matters for the landscaper. She has twenty years of digging behind her and a lot of certainty, and when she is right she tends to lead with the answer. That patio will flood. The people across from her are not stupid, and when they do not take her answer, it is usually not because the answer is bad. They are doing what the research says everyone does with a flat disagreement from someone who has not shown they understood the original position. They defend. The homeowner hears that her idea is foolish, and starts explaining why she wants the patio flush with the wall. And once someone is defending, the quality of your argument stops being the thing they respond to. Being ignored is what that feels like from your side.

    Two notes for anyone who works for customers. First, a customer can simply stop calling you. On a crew, an ignored idea comes back around at the next morning briefing. A homeowner who feels argued with just hires someone else for the next job, and you find out in the spring when the phone stays quiet. So the opening matters more with customers, not less. Second, an accountant or an advisor is someone you are paying to disagree with you. With them the restatement does a different job. If you cannot say back their concern in a way they would sign, you do not understand the risk yet, and you are about to overrule something you have not heard.

    There is a useful test buried in the first rule. If you cannot restate their position in a way they would agree with, you do not disagree with them yet. You disagree with your guess about them. When that happens the right move is not to argue. It is to ask. Let me make sure I have this. You want the patio flush with the wall because you want one step out of the kitchen door, with no lip to trip on. Is that right. Half the time you will find the position was not what you thought. Maybe she only cares about the step, and a slight slope away from the house gives her exactly that. The other half, you will have bought the thing that makes the disagreement land.

    One thing to try today. There is a message somewhere, an email, a note on a quote, a reply after a phone call, where you think someone is wrong and you have either pushed once or are about to. Before you write the pushback, write three short lines above it. One sentence stating their position the way they would state it. One thing you agree with, a real one. One thing you learned from what they said. Then the disagreement, and hedge it. I might be missing something, but. Then read the whole thing back and cut anything that sounds like a verdict. Send that instead. Watch what comes back. If you get a real reply instead of silence, you have the tool. It works on people who pay you as well as it works on people you pay.

    That is the lesson. You do not have to be less right. You have to earn the right to be heard, and the research says it costs you four sentences.

    Key terms

    Rapoport's rules
    Four steps for criticism: restate the other view fairly, list agreements, name what you learned, and only then disagree.
    Conversational receptiveness
    Using words that show you have heard an opposing view, such as acknowledging it, hedging your claims, framing positively and finding agreement.
    Restatement test
    If you cannot state someone's position in a way they would agree with, you are disagreeing with your guess about them, so ask first.

    Say it back

    1. What problem is this lesson helping you avoid?
    2. What is the first move you would make?
    3. Where could you use this in your next conversation?