← School

Free course

Communicating and leading, a lesson every weekday

A short daily lesson on saying the hard thing, asking for what you need, writing that works without you, and leading people. One framework, one story, one thing to try today.

Name two times: get a meeting on the calendar with one message.

Newest lesson · Lesson 68 · 5:51

You learn to schedule a meeting in one message by naming two specific times, stating your preference, and leaving an easy way out.

Listen to the lesson
  1. 63.Give the note, not the fix: tell someone what is wrong with their work so it comes back better.6:11You learn to give feedback as a specific symptom and purpose rather than a fix, so the person who made the work can find the real cause.
    Play lesson
    6:11

    Imagine you are the head chef of a small neighborhood restaurant. Your name is Rosa, there are eleven tables, and the menu changes with the season. Every afternoon at four, before service, the kitchen eats together, and anyone with a new dish puts it on the pass for everyone to taste. This week it is a squash soup with brown butter and sage, from your sous chef. You will taste it, and you will have notes. Today's lesson is how to give them so the next version comes back better, and not just different.

    Rosa already knows this from the other side of the pass. Before she ran a kitchen, she cooked in other people's, and plates came back to her. Needs more salt. Too rich. Can it be hotter. And she learned to translate. When a table said it needs salt, it was often not about salt at all. Usually the soup had sat too long and gone lukewarm, and a cool soup tastes flat. Once she heard the real complaint, she could fix it a better way than a heavier hand with the salt. The diner handed her a fix. What she needed was the problem.

    Now she is the one giving notes, all day, and many of them to the newest cooks. A new prep cook does not translate the way she learned to. Tell him to cut the onions smaller and you get smaller onions. Exactly that. If the real trouble was that they went into the pan too late and stayed crunchy, they are still crunchy. They are just smaller.

    Pixar runs on this idea. Ed Catmull ran the studio, and in his book Creativity, Inc. he describes the Braintrust, the group that watches each film while it is still rough. Two of its rules matter here. First, the Braintrust has no authority. The director hears the notes and decides what to do with them. Second, a good note says what is wrong, what is missing, what is not clear, what makes no sense. It does not have to carry a fix. If it does, the fix is only there to show what you mean. And above all, the note is specific. So a note like the middle drags is no help. A note like this one is: in this scene, at this moment, I stopped caring whether she got out.

    Why hold back the fix when you can see one? The film editor Walter Murch has the answer, in his book In the Blink of an Eye, where he talks about referred pain. A test audience points at one scene and says, that is the problem. They are right that it hurts there. But a sore elbow can come from a pinched nerve in the shoulder, and the cause of a bad scene is often sitting earlier in the film. Fix the spot they pointed at and you have operated on the elbow. A kitchen works the same way. The soup tastes muddy, but the cause may be the stock made that morning. So the work splits in two. The person tasting knows where it hurt. The person who cooked it is the one who can find out why. You own the symptom. They own the cause.

    Now the part about people, because this is where a note can do real damage. In nineteen ninety six, two researchers, Avraham Kluger and Angelo DeNisi, gathered about six hundred measured effects of feedback from decades of studies. On average, feedback helped. But in more than a third of the cases, feedback made performance worse. Not useless. Worse. What separated the two was where the feedback sent the person's attention. Notes that kept attention on the task helped. Notes that pulled attention toward the self, toward what kind of cook am I, hurt. That covers the harsh ones. It also covers praise. Telling someone they are so talented moves their eye off the plate just as surely as telling them they blew it. So when Rosa gives her sous chef or anyone else a note, she keeps it on the bowl, the bite, the temperature. Never on them.

    Eleven years later, John Hattie and Helen Timperley added the piece that turns this into something you can use. Useful feedback, they said, answers three questions for the person getting it. Where is this going? How is it going? What comes next? Think about the usual note at a tasting. It says, this is off. That answers the middle question and skips the first one, what the dish was supposed to do.

    So here is a note you can use today. It has three parts.

    Where. A spoonful, a component, a moment on the plate. One spot.

    What happened to me. What you tasted, saw or felt as the person eating. I got nothing but vinegar on the second bite. The sage burned my tongue before the squash arrived. I stopped eating halfway.

    What it was for. The job that dish has. This is the course that is supposed to warm people up and make them settle in.

    Then stop. If you have a fix in mind, offer it as a for instance, and call it that. And say which notes have to change and which are only your taste. People treat every note as an order unless you tell them it is not.

    The same skill runs backward. When a regular, or the couple booking the back room for a birthday dinner, asks for a change, it often arrives shaped like a fix. Make it less spicy. Leave off the sauce. You are allowed to ask what was bothering them. One sentence does it. What were you tasting that made you want that? You are not arguing with the note. You are getting the note behind it, the one a good cook learns to hear.

    One thing to try today. Take the next piece of someone else's work you need to judge, and go through it once, straight through, without stopping to comment. Then give three notes in that shape. Where, what happened to you, what it was for. No fixes. Send them and see what comes back. The bet is that a builder working from the problem beats a builder working from your order. Then do the same with the next person you give a note to this week, and leave them the decision.

    That is the lesson. Most people have stood on the receiving end of notes, so they know what a good one felt like. Say where it hurt. Let the builder find the shoulder.

    Key terms

    Referred pain
    Murch's idea that the place where a piece of work seems to hurt is often not where the real cause sits.
    The Braintrust
    Pixar's group that gives specific notes on rough films but has no authority, leaving the decision to the director.
    Three questions of feedback
    Hattie and Timperley's idea that useful feedback says where the work is going, how it is going and what comes next.

    Say it back

    1. What problem is this lesson helping you avoid?
    2. What is the first move you would make?
    3. Where could you use this in your next conversation?