← School

Free course

Communicating and leading, a lesson every weekday

A short daily lesson on saying the hard thing, asking for what you need, writing that works without you, and leading people. One framework, one story, one thing to try today.

Name two times: get a meeting on the calendar with one message.

Newest lesson · Lesson 68 · 5:51

You learn to schedule a meeting in one message by naming two specific times, stating your preference, and leaving an easy way out.

Listen to the lesson
  1. 57.Ask the second question: the person who asks the follow-up is the one who gets heard.7:24You learn why asking follow-up questions and paraphrasing before giving your answer makes people like you, feel understood, and reveal the real problem.
    Play lesson
    7:24

    Imagine you run a small landscaping company with two crews, one van, and a trailer that needs new tires. Today's lesson is about the moment in a conversation when the other person finishes a sentence and you already know what you want to say. You have the answer. You have had it since halfway through their sentence. For the landscaper, that moment comes up in the conversations that matter most. A homeowner standing in the yard describing what is wrong with it. A property manager who looks after six apartment buildings and is describing what she wants from a seasonal contract. The whole lesson comes down to one instruction for that moment. Do not say it yet. Ask a question about what they just said. Then ask another one.

    Start with the study that made this concrete. In twenty seventeen, Karen Huang, Michael Yeomans, Alison Wood Brooks, Julia Minson and Francesca Gino at Harvard published a paper in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology called It Doesn't Hurt to Ask. Pairs of strangers chatted online for fifteen minutes. Some were told to ask at least nine questions in that time, others four at most. Afterward, the partners rated how much they liked the person they had talked to. The people who asked more questions were liked more. Then the authors ran the same analysis on real speed dating, and the people who asked more follow-up questions got more second dates.

    The part that matters most is what kind of question. They sorted every question into types. Opening ones, how are you. Ones that switch the subject. Mirror questions, where you ask back what you were just asked. And follow-up questions, which build on what the other person just said. The follow-up carried most of the effect. The authors are clear about why. A follow-up question is proof that you listened. You cannot write it in advance, because you cannot write it until they have spoken. Every other question could have been prepared. The follow-up is the receipt.

    Now the second study, because being liked and being heard are different, and for most work the second matters more. In twenty fourteen, Harry Weger and his colleagues at the University of Central Florida published a paper in the International Journal of Listening on active listening in first conversations. Each person had a short talk with a trained partner, who responded in one of three ways. Simple acknowledgment, the nods and the yes I see. Advice, a suggestion for what to do. Or active listening, which in the study meant the listener put what they had heard into their own words and asked a question about it. The people who got the paraphrase and the question felt more understood than either of the other groups. Here is the honest detail. The advice givers were liked about as much as the active listeners, and advice beat the bare nod. So advice is not poison. It is just not the thing that makes a person feel understood. The thing quick, capable people are best at, the fast, correct, useful suggestion, came second to a sentence that said back what the other person had said.

    That explains a common pattern. Plenty of people who are good at solving problems notice that their solutions get ignored, and when they look closely, it is not about the quality of the solutions. It is about the order. A solution that arrives before the other person feels understood is not taken as help. It is taken as a verdict on what they were saying, and people defend against verdicts. The landscaper tells a homeowner, before he has finished talking, that the soggy corner of the lawn needs a drain, and he folds his arms and says he will think about it.

    There is a third piece, and it should change how you think about listening. Guy Itzchakov and Avraham Kluger have spent a decade studying what happens to the speaker when the listener is good. In a twenty seventeen paper in the Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, with Dotan Castro, they had people talk about a topic to a listener who was either attentive or distracted. The people with the attentive listener came out less anxious, more aware of both sides of their own view, and holding it less extremely. Nobody argued with them. Nobody presented the other side. They were listened to, and the listening did what an argument could not. If you want someone to move, the argument is the weakest tool you have. The question is the strongest.

    Now the business reason, which is plain. The first thing a customer tells you is rarely the real problem. It is the symptom they can name. If you answer the first sentence, you build a fast, correct solution to the wrong thing, and you find out after a crew has spent a Saturday on it. The same goes for the property manager who says she is interested in a contract. The first sentence tells you she is interested. Only the follow-up tells you in what, on what terms, and by when. The second question is not manners. It is how you find out what you are actually being asked for.

    So here is the practice, and it has three moves in a fixed order. Chris Voss, the former FBI hostage negotiator, lays out the first two in Never Split the Difference, from twenty sixteen. The first is the mirror. Repeat the last one to three words the other person said, as a question, and then stop. If a homeowner says, the yard never looks finished, you say, never looks finished? and you wait. People fill silence. They will tell you the next layer, which is usually the real thing. The second is the label. You say what you think they are feeling or wanting, as an observation. It sounds like you have been bothered by this for a while. If you are wrong they will correct you, which is also information. The third move is the one Weger tested. The paraphrase. Say back the whole thing in one sentence and let them fix it. So what I am hearing is, the mowing is fine, but the edges and the leaves along the fence make the place look neglected. Is that it. Only after they say yes, that is it, do you say the thing that arrived in your head six minutes ago. And by then it will have changed, because you know more than you did when it arrived.

    This is hard for quick people, and it is not a character flaw. It is speed. Some people see the shape of a problem faster than most. The other person does not experience that speed as help. They experience it as not being heard. The fix is not to get slower. It is to spend the speed on finding the follow-up question instead of the answer.

    One thing to try today. Pick one conversation, a call, an email thread, a message, and set a rule for it. You do not make your point until you have asked two follow-up questions about theirs and said their position back in one sentence they agreed with. Two questions, one paraphrase, then you. Count them. It will feel slow, and it will feel like giving up ground. Watch what happens to the point you make afterward.

    That is the lesson. The person who asks the follow-up question is the one who gets liked, the one who gets trusted, and the one who learns what the job really is. The answer you have is probably right. Ask the second question anyway.

    Key terms

    Follow-up question
    A question that builds on what the other person just said, which proves you were listening.
    Active listening
    Putting what you heard into your own words and asking a question about it before offering anything of your own.
    Mirror
    Repeating the last one to three words someone said, as a question, and then waiting for them to say more.

    Say it back

    1. What problem is this lesson helping you avoid?
    2. What is the first move you would make?
    3. Where could you use this in your next conversation?