← School

Free course

Communicating and leading, a lesson every weekday

A short daily lesson on saying the hard thing, asking for what you need, writing that works without you, and leading people. One framework, one story, one thing to try today.

Name two times: get a meeting on the calendar with one message.

Newest lesson · Lesson 68 · 5:51

You learn to schedule a meeting in one message by naming two specific times, stating your preference, and leaving an easy way out.

Listen to the lesson
  1. 64.Ask before you prescribe: why the expert in the room should be the last one to offer a fix.6:39You learn why experts should ask what someone needs, and say it back, before offering any fix, even when they already think they know the answer.
    Play lesson
    6:39

    Imagine you are an independent bookkeeper who has worked on your own for nine years. One of your longtime clients, a man who runs a small bakery, has asked you to sit in on a meeting with a friend of his. The friend owns a garden nursery on the edge of town, with two greenhouses, a gift shop and a dozen seasonal staff. Your client calls her sharp, and new to all this. You were only invited as a favour, but once you are at the table, you are the expert in the room. Today's lesson is about the hardest part of that job: keeping the fix to yourself until she has told you what she needs.

    Here is why it is hard for the bookkeeper in particular. She already has an answer. The night before, she looked through the notes her client sent over and the nursery's own website. She found that every sale already runs through the till system at the gift shop. Every plant and every bag of compost is recorded there, but none of it reaches the accounts, which someone retypes by hand each month. She also found that whether that till system can send its numbers anywhere depends on which plan the nursery pays for. All of that is true, and some of it will matter. And all of it is a trap, because the more you know walking in, the stronger the pull to start with what you know.

    There is a study about exactly this pull. In two thousand eighteen, a team at the University of Florida and the Mayo Clinic, led by Naykky Singh Ospina, watched the opening minutes of a hundred and twelve recorded medical visits. Only about a third of the time did the clinician ask the patient what they came in for. When patients did get to start, the clinician cut in after about eleven seconds, on average. The patients nobody interrupted were done talking in about six seconds. So letting them finish would have cost almost nothing. And here is the part that matters for anyone with expertise. The specialists interrupted more than the family physicians. The researchers' best guess: a specialist already knows why the patient was sent to them, so they skip the question.

    The bookkeeper is the specialist at this meeting. Her client's notes are the referral. The nursery owner wants, in his words, tidier books and to be more efficient. That is what the patient told the receptionist. It is not yet what she wants.

    Edgar Schein spent his career at MIT on what goes wrong when one person helps another. In his book Helping, he names three roles a helper can take. The expert, who hands over information or a service. The doctor, who diagnoses and prescribes. And what he calls the process consultant, who starts by working out with the person what kind of help they actually need. His rule is that you open in the third role, and only move to the other two once the problem is clear. Open as the doctor and you risk solving the wrong problem, because the person never got the chance to work out what theirs was.

    Schein adds a reason that is about status. Asking for help puts a person one down. The nursery owner is a successful owner about to sit with someone who knows far more about money and records than she does. She walks in one down already. A fair reading of that is this: if the bookkeeper's first move is to show what she found, the owner slides further down, and an owner in that spot tends to nod along and say that sounds great instead of saying what she thinks. Schein's answer is what he calls humble inquiry: drawing someone out by asking questions you do not know the answer to. Not quiz questions you already solved the night before.

    Now the money side, because this is a sales conversation whether anyone calls it one or not. Rackham's team studied more than thirty five thousand sales calls for his book SPIN Selling. On big deals, a fix pitched for a need the buyer had only hinted at drew pushback on price. The same fix landed when the buyer had said the need out loud first. So the questions are not politeness before the pitch. They are how the need gets said out loud, by the one person who has to pay for it.

    So here is how the bookkeeper runs the first part of the meeting. Four questions, in this order.

    First, what the owner wants, in her words. Ask her to pick. If this worked, would you have a clearer picture of where the money goes, or fewer evenings spent on paperwork? Those lead to different jobs, and only she knows which one she means.

    Second, what she already pays for and uses. What runs the business today? Who set it up, and who keeps it running? This is where the till system comes up, and the plan she is on, and the bookkeeper learns it from her instead of telling her.

    Third, what she has already tried. Has she or anyone on her staff kept the books themselves, or used a bookkeeping program before? That is the first clue to whether she wants tools she runs herself, or someone to do it for her.

    Fourth, what it would be worth. If one piece of this were sorted in a month, what would that be worth to you?

    Then say back what she said, in one sentence, using her own words, and ask if that is right. Let her correct it. Only after she says yes, that is it, does the bookkeeper offer one thing. One fixed piece of work, with a price and a finish line, not a tour of everything she could do.

    And the finding about the till? Hold it, and when it fits, turn it into a question. Something like: It looks as if every sale already goes through the till in the gift shop. Does anyone use those numbers for the accounts, or are they kept separately for now? Same fact. But now the owner is the one explaining her business, and the bookkeeper is the one learning it.

    One more thing. This is the client's friend and the client's meeting. If he jumps to the pitch, which he may, the bookkeeper can bring it back without overruling him. Something like: Before we get to options, can I ask what a good result looks like for you?

    One thing to try today. In your next conversation where you are the expert, make no recommendation for the first ten minutes. Ask the four questions, say back what the person wants, and get a yes. Then offer one thing. Afterward, put what they actually said next to whatever you prepared beforehand, and notice what your preparation got wrong.

    That is the lesson. You will often walk in with the answer. Leave it in your pocket until the other person has told you the question.

    Key terms

    Process consultant
    Edgar Schein's name for a helper who first works out with the person what kind of help they actually need before diagnosing or advising.
    Humble inquiry
    Drawing someone out with genuine questions you do not already know the answer to, so they can explain their own situation.
    Stated need
    A need the buyer has said out loud themselves, which makes a later offer land far better than one pitched at a need they only hinted at.

    Say it back

    1. What problem is this lesson helping you avoid?
    2. What is the first move you would make?
    3. Where could you use this in your next conversation?