← School

Free course

Communicating and leading, a lesson every weekday

A short daily lesson on saying the hard thing, asking for what you need, writing that works without you, and leading people. One framework, one story, one thing to try today.

Name two times: get a meeting on the calendar with one message.

Newest lesson · Lesson 68 · 5:51

You learn to schedule a meeting in one message by naming two specific times, stating your preference, and leaving an easy way out.

Listen to the lesson
  1. 51.Stop reading minds: ask instead of guessing.6:09You learn why guessing what someone thinks rarely works, and how perspective getting, asking directly, replaces two guesses with one shared fact.
    Play lesson
    6:09

    Imagine you run a small bakery that is trying to grow. You spend much of every day working out what other people are thinking. A café owner tasted your sourdough last week and said she would love to carry it. Does that mean an order is coming, or was it a pleasant moment? Your flour supplier has not answered two messages. Is something wrong, or is it simply a busy week? Your new morning baker went quiet after you changed the schedule. Is she upset, or just tired? The habit of guessing has a name in the research, and the research has a surprising verdict on it.

    Start with how good people actually are at this. William Ickes at the University of Texas at Arlington spent thirty years measuring what he calls empathic accuracy. The method is simple. Two people have a conversation on video. Afterward each one watches the tape, stops it at moments where they remember having a specific thought or feeling, and writes it down. Then the other person watches the same tape, stops at the same points, and guesses what their partner was thinking. You score the guesses against the real thoughts. Strangers come in around twenty percent. Close friends, people who have had years to learn each other, come in around thirty, and married couples about the same or a little higher. Ickes says almost nobody scores above sixty. So the default state of mind reading is that you are wrong most of the time, even about the people you know best. And as Nicholas Epley puts it in his book Mindwise, our confidence in what we know about other people's minds runs well ahead of our accuracy.

    Now the part that matters for how you run a conversation. Epley, at the University of Chicago, has spent a career on this. In two thousand eighteen, with Tal Eyal and Mary Steffel, he published a paper in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology with a title that gives away the finding. Perspective Mistaking. They ran twenty five experiments. In each one, people tried to work out what someone else thought, felt or preferred, from jokes to opinions to what their own spouse would want. Some were told to take the other person's perspective, to really imagine being them, which is the advice every management book gives. It did not help. If anything it made accuracy a little worse, and sometimes it left people more sure. The thing that did work, in their final experiment, was what they called perspective getting. Asking the person directly and listening to the answer. It sounds too obvious to be a finding. It is a finding because almost nobody does it, and because the alternative feels like empathy while it produces errors.

    There is a companion study from Epley's lab, Zhou, Majka and Epley in Psychological Science in twenty seventeen, that explains why the shortcut is so tempting. People underestimate how much they would learn by asking, or by being in the other person's place, compared with imagining it. Imagining feels like information. It is not. It is your own model of them, running on your own assumptions, and it hands your assumptions back to you dressed as their thoughts.

    Here is how this goes wrong for the baker. On a bad night, the problem is not that she gets a fact wrong. It is that she fills a silence with a story about what someone thinks of her, and then answers the story. The supplier must be annoyed about the late payment in the spring. The morning baker must be looking for another job. At two in the morning she is an excellent perspective taker and a terrible perspective getter. Under stress the story is usually the least generous one, because a stressed brain looks for threats, not for the boring explanation. And most of the time the boring explanation is the right one. The supplier's office manager was out sick.

    The error can run the other way too, and that one is often more expensive. When things are going well and you like the person, you can read a friendly sentence as a commitment. We should talk about that is not a yes. I would love to carry your bread is not a standing order. Hope reads minds as badly as fear does. It just guesses in the pleasant direction. And a bakery that buys a second oven around a guess about someone else's orders is planning around its own assumption, dressed as their thought.

    So the tool is stupidly simple and hard to use. When you notice you have written someone's thought for them, that is the cue. Not to take their perspective harder. To get it. Ask the question you are pretending to already know the answer to. After a quiet few days, it sounds like: are you waiting on me for anything here. With a customer it sounds like: what would make this a clear yes for you. With the café owner who said she would love to carry the bread, it sounds like: when you say you would love to, what would the first order look like, and when. That last one feels forward. It is not. It is the kindest thing you can do for both of you, because it replaces two different guesses with one shared fact.

    The question costs you nothing except the feeling of already knowing. The research says that feeling was never worth anything.

    One thing to try today. Pick one person you are going to talk to this week whose view matters to your next month. Before the conversation, write down one sentence: what you think they currently believe about your work, or about what happens next. Then, in the conversation, ask them. Compare. Do this once and you will have a data point on your own accuracy that is worth more than anything this lesson can tell you. Do it for a week and you will start to feel the difference between a guess and a fact as it happens. That is the whole skill.

    That is the lesson. Nobody is good at reading minds. People who have known each other for decades are still wrong most of the time. Trying harder makes you more sure and not more right. The only method that works is the one that feels like cheating. Ask.

    Key terms

    empathic accuracy
    Empathic accuracy is how closely your guess about someone's thoughts matches what they were actually thinking.
    perspective taking
    Perspective taking means imagining yourself in another person's place to infer what they think.
    perspective getting
    Perspective getting means asking the person directly and listening to the answer.

    Say it back

    1. What problem is this lesson helping you avoid?
    2. What is the first move you would make?
    3. Where could you use this in your next conversation?